Thumb-Sucking vs. Dummies: How Do They Compare?

For teeth, they are more alike than different. Both can cause the same bite changes if they continue for a long time, and in both cases the bite often corrects itself once the habit stops. The main difference is practical: a dummy can be phased out by you, while a thumb is always available. 

Key Takeaways 

  • Thumb-sucking and dummy use are both normal in early childhood and cause the same type of bite changes when they go on for years. 
  • The risk rises with duration, not with which habit it is.
  • Dummy use beyond two to three years is linked to more bite problems.
  • When children stop either habit, the bite often corrects itself, even after age four. 

Do They Affect Teeth Differently? 

Not in any way that research has clearly shown. A review of 17 studies linked longer dummy use to open bite and posterior crossbite. The 2023 review of children who stopped sucking habits covered thumb and dummy habits together, so it doesn’t split the results between the two. 

Two bite changes are worth knowing about: 

  • Open bite: the front teeth don’t meet when your child bites down. 
  • Posterior crossbite: the upper back teeth sit inside the lower ones, usually because the upper jaw is narrow. 

The honest answer is that what matters most is how long and how often a habit continues. The research isn’t perfect, but it’s enough to give a sensible goal: try to move on from either habit by around age two to three. 

Does Age Change Things? 

Age matters mainly because of timing. Dummy use beyond two to three years carries a higher risk of bite changes than shorter use. For thumb-sucking, there’s no research-based cut-off, so the practical guide is whether the habit is continuing as your child moves beyond the preschool years. 

Many parents worry that if the habit lasts past age four, the damage is permanent. Often it isn’t. A 2023 review found that open bites corrected themselves in around half to all of the children who stopped, even after age four. Very few corrected in children who kept the habit going. It isn’t guaranteed, and some bites don’t settle, but there’s no need to panic if stopping takes time. 

Where Are You Now? A Quick Guide by Age 

These age bands are a practical guide, not research cut-offs. The reviews only point to dummy use beyond two to three years as a higher-risk point, and they don’t set an age for thumb-sucking. Every child is different, so use this as a starting point. 

Under 2 Years: No Need to Act Yet 

Both habits are normal at this age. The research links the higher risk of bite changes to use beyond two years, so this is a good time to start thinking about how you’ll move on. If you use a dummy, you can begin limiting it to sleep times. 

2 to 3 Years: A Good Time to Start Moving On 

This is the point where longer dummy use becomes linked to more bite changes, so it’s a sensible window to phase the dummy out. For thumb-sucking, it’s a good time to start gentle encouragement. Notice when it happens (tiredness, boredom or stress are common triggers) and offer comfort or distraction instead of pressure. 

3 to 4 Years: Keep Encouraging, and Mention It at a Check-Up 

If either habit is still going, there’s no cause for alarm, but it’s worth mentioning at your next dental check-up. Your dentist can check how the teeth are meeting and tell you whether anything needs watching. 

4 Years and Older: Still Plenty of Reason for Hope 

The 2023 review found that open bites often corrected themselves after children stopped, even after age four, so a later start isn’t a lost cause. If the habit is continuing, or you’ve noticed the front teeth not meeting or a narrow upper jaw, ask your dentist whether a referral to a specialist orthodontist makes sense. 

At Any Age: Check the Breathing Too 

If your child breathes through their mouth most of the time, snores regularly or seems tired during the day, see your GP first. This is a separate issue from sucking habits, and it’s usually caused by something in the nose or throat. 

Which Is Easier to Stop? 

This is where the two differ most, though it’s a practical difference, not a research finding. 

  • Dummies: you control when the dummy is offered, so you can limit it to sleep times, then phase it out. 
  • Thumb-sucking: your child has the habit with them at all times, so it usually relies on gentle encouragement and patience, and on working out what triggers it (tiredness, boredom, stress). 

Whichever habit it is, a calm approach tends to work better than pressure. 

Are “Orthodontic” Dummies Better? 

Probably not by much. The research found no clear benefit from orthodontic-style dummies in preventing crossbite. Thin-neck dummies may cause slightly less open bite, but that rests on a single trial. How long your child uses a dummy matters more than which type it is. 

When Should I Be Concerned? 

There’s no magic age. Instead, watch for these signs: 

  • The front teeth don’t meet when your child bites together. 
  • The upper jaw looks narrow, or the back teeth sit the wrong way across from each other. 
  • The habit is still going as your child heads towards school age. 

None of these means your child needs treatment. They are simply good reasons to bring it up at your next dental check-up. 

What About Mouth Breathing? 

Mouth breathing is a different question from sucking habits, but parents often wonder about both. Children who breathe through their mouth tend to have slightly different jaw angles and narrower airways. A review of 10 studies found this link, but it can’t prove that mouth breathing causes it. 

The practical point is that mouth breathing is usually a sign of something blocking the nose or throat, most often enlarged adenoids or tonsils. See your GP first. Also mention it if your child snores regularly, sleeps badly or is often tired in the day. 

Why See a Specialist Orthodontist? 

Whether a habit is affecting your child’s development is a clinical judgement. Some bite changes settle on their own, some just need monitoring, and some benefit from treatment.  

Members of the New Zealand Association of Orthodontists (NZAO) have completed two to three years of full-time postgraduate training beyond their dental degree. An NZAO-registered specialist orthodontist can tell you which applies to your child.

Frequently Asked Questions 

Is Thumb-Sucking Worse Than a Dummy? 

Research hasn’t shown a clear difference for teeth. Both can cause open bite and crossbite if they continue for a long time. A dummy is easier to phase out, while a thumb is always available. 

At What Age Should My Child Stop? 

There’s no set age. For dummies, aim for around two to three years, as longer use is linked to more bite changes. For thumb-sucking, raise it with your dentist if it continues past the preschool years. 

If My Child Stops, Will Their Teeth Fix Themselves? 

Often, yes. Many open bites correct after the habit stops, even after age four, but it isn’t guaranteed. 

Do Orthodontic Dummies Prevent Problems? 

There’s no clear evidence they do. Limiting how long your child uses a dummy matters more than the type. 

Can Mouth Breathing Change My Child’s Face? 

It’s linked to small differences in jaw growth, but this isn’t proven. Mouth breathing is usually caused by something in the nose or throat, so see your GP first. 

Will My Child Need Braces Because of a Sucking Habit? 

Not necessarily. Many bite changes settle once the habit stops. A specialist can tell you if yours is likely to. 

Find a Registered Specialist Orthodontist 

If you’re unsure whether your child’s habit is affecting their teeth, you can find a registered specialist through the NZAO directory.